• Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact AskFlagler
AskFlagler
Subscribe
  • Breaking News
  • Politics
    • County Commission
    • Palm Coast City Council
    • School Board
  • Sheriff
  • Historical
  • Community
    • Things to Do
  • Advertise
70.95 °f
Palm Coast
72.54875 ° Fri
67.72375 ° Sat
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
No Result
View All Result
AskFlagler
  • Breaking News
  • Politics
    • County Commission
    • Palm Coast City Council
    • School Board
  • Sheriff
  • Historical
  • Community
    • Things to Do
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
AskFlagler
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Crime

Florida Appeals Court Rules Odor of Marijuana Not Probable Cause for Search

Chris Gollon by Chris Gollon
October 7, 2025
in Crime, Sheriff / Court, State Politics
27
0

ⓒ Michael Fischer | Pexels

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

An appeals court in Florida has ruled that the smell of marijuana no longer constitutes probable cause for a search by law enforcement. The ruling was handed down on October 2nd by the Florida Second District Court of Appeal, striking down the ‘plain smell doctrine’.

Prior to this ruling, law enforcement officers conducting a traffic stop could initiate a search if they smelled marijuana, and have that search justified by probable cause. Now, they’ll need to supplement that with additional factors such as visible impairment, suspicious behavior, or plainly visible drug paraphernalia.

Officers are still authorized to conduct a search if they have a warrant, if the vehicle has been lawfully impounded, probable cause stems from another factor, or if the vehicle’s operator provides consent to a search.

RelatedPosts

Bunnell Woman Arrested for Forging Deeds, Selling Vacant Lot

Randy Fine Fends Off Eric Yonce, Wins 2 More Years in Congress

Florida’s Amendment 3 Passes, Expanding Homestead Tax Exemption

Ashley Moody Retains U.S. Senate Seat

Case Background

The case which changed Florida law was brought by Darrielle Ortiz Williams and his attorneys appealing the revocation of Williams’ probation in Hillsborough County. It was argued that the basis for Williams’ arrest was merely the smell of cannabis, and that due to changes in applicable federal and state laws this was no longer reason enough for an arrest. The courts agreed.

The relevant changes in law leading to the overturning of the plain smell doctrine include the widespread legalization of marijuana, both medically and recreationally, in jurisdictions across the country. Medical marijuana is legal and regulated in Florida, while recreational marijuana remains illegal.

Williams served over a decade in prison for attempted first-degree murder, being released in 2023. That same year he was a passenger in a car which was pulled over for allegedly failing to come to a complete stop leaving a private lot and for having an obstructed license plate. Two officers testified to smelling marijuana, and conducted a search. They discovered cannabis and ecstasy. Williams was found to have violated his probation, based on evidence discovered in a search that was initiated solely due to marijuana smell.

Probable Cause and the Fourth Amendment

“We agree that legislative changes over the years to the definition and regulation of cannabis have eliminated the continuing validity of the plain smell doctrine in this context,” the ruling states. “We accordingly hold that, under the updated statutory text, the smell of cannabis standing alone is insufficient to establish probable cause.”

The ruling went on to cite protections guaranteed under the Fourth Amendment, which prevents unreasonable searches and seizures. The Fourth Amendment is the reason search warrants are required in most cases. In the 1961 Supreme Court decision Mapp v. Ohio, it was ruled that these protections work against local and state governments thanks to the Fourteenth Amendment right to due process.

Tags: cannabiscourtdarrielle ortiz williamsfourth amendmentlaw enforcementmarijuanaplain smell doctrineprobable cause
Advertisement Banner
Chris Gollon

Chris Gollon

Chris Gollon is a Flagler County resident since 2004, as well as a staple of the local independent music scene and avid observer of Central Florida politics, arts, and recreation.

Related Posts

Bunnell Woman Arrested for Forging Deeds, Selling Vacant Lot

Bunnell Woman Arrested for Forging Deeds, Selling Vacant Lot

by Chris Gollon
November 10, 2026
1

A Bunnell resident was arrested last week for allegedly creating fake deeds to sell vacant lots that didn't belong to...

Randy Fine Fends Off Eric Yonce, Wins 2 More Years in Congress

Randy Fine Fends Off Eric Yonce, Wins 2 More Years in Congress

by Chris Gollon
November 4, 2026
0

Incumbent congressman Randy Fine won re-election on Tuesday, sealing his first full two-year term in office. A Republican, Fine defeated...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement Banner Advertisement Banner Advertisement Banner
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

FEATURED POST

Ty Miller Appointed Palm Coast Vice Mayor

Ty Miller Appointed Palm Coast Vice Mayor

November 18, 2026
Eric Cooley, Patti King Won’t Seek Re-Election in Flagler Beach

Eric Cooley, Patti King Won’t Seek Re-Election in Flagler Beach

November 17, 2026
Palm Coast’s Patrick Juliano Earns Chief Fire Officer Designation

Palm Coast’s Patrick Juliano Earns Chief Fire Officer Designation

November 16, 2026
Palm Coast Tree Lighting Set for November 28

Palm Coast Tree Lighting Set for November 28

November 12, 2026

EDITOR PICK'S

Ty Miller Appointed Palm Coast Vice Mayor

November 18, 2026

Eric Cooley, Patti King Won’t Seek Re-Election in Flagler Beach

November 17, 2026

Palm Coast’s Patrick Juliano Earns Chief Fire Officer Designation

November 16, 2026

Palm Coast Tree Lighting Set for November 28

November 12, 2026

Rick Staly Prepping for Major Budget Cuts After Amendment 3 Passage

November 11, 2026

Bunnell Woman Arrested for Forging Deeds, Selling Vacant Lot

November 10, 2026

Pennington Re-Elected, Pontieri Wins County Commission Seat

November 5, 2026
Your source for comprehensive local news in Flagler County. Celebrating six years of reporting about Flagler County, Palm Coast and Bunnell.

Recent News

Ty Miller Appointed Palm Coast Vice Mayor

Ty Miller Appointed Palm Coast Vice Mayor

November 18, 2026
Eric Cooley, Patti King Won’t Seek Re-Election in Flagler Beach

Eric Cooley, Patti King Won’t Seek Re-Election in Flagler Beach

November 17, 2026
Palm Coast’s Patrick Juliano Earns Chief Fire Officer Designation

Palm Coast’s Patrick Juliano Earns Chief Fire Officer Designation

November 16, 2026
Palm Coast Tree Lighting Set for November 28

Palm Coast Tree Lighting Set for November 28

November 12, 2026

Advertise With Us

85,000+ monthly page views from engaged local readers.

Full monthly reporting showing exactly how many people saw and clicked your ad.

Know your cost-per-click, cost-per-impression, and actual ROI No guessing.

No “hope marketing.” Just data.

  • Breaking News
  • Politics
  • Sheriff
  • Historical
  • Community
  • Advertise

© 2026 AskFlagler.com. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Breaking News
  • Politics
    • County Commission
    • Palm Coast City Council
    • School Board
  • Sheriff
  • Historical
  • Community
    • Things to Do
  • Advertise

© 2026 AskFlagler.com. All Rights Reserved.